Rethinking Plasma Partnerships: Toward an Adaptive Institutional Governance Model for Sustainable Oil Palm Development

Authors:
Lavenia Lauwinata, Simon Ebel Masris Phoek, Paul Adryani Moento, K.  Balasubramanian, Hind Hammouch

Addresses:
Department of Management, STIE Saint Theresa, Merauke, South Papua, Indonesia. Department of Political Science, Faculty of Social and Political Sciences, Universitas Musamus, Merauke, South Papua, Indonesia. Faculty of Business and Commerce, ISBAT University, Kampala, Central Region, Uganda. Department of Economics and Management, Sidi Mohamed Ben Abdellah University, Fez, Fez-Meknès, Morocco.

Abstract:

Sustainable plasma partnerships integrate smallholders into commercial plantation systems to promote inclusive oil palm development. Institutional issues include fragmented governance, land tenure uncertainty, unequal bargaining power, and insufficient stakeholder coordination, which limit these partnerships' efficacy. Most studies of plasma partnerships focus on contractual, commercial, or certification perspectives, with little emphasis on institutional governance processes and long-term performance. This study examines institutional governance mechanisms affecting plasma partnership implementation in South Papua, Indonesia, and develops an AIGM for sustainable palm oil production. A qualitative case study was conducted utilising data from 25 key interviewees from government agencies, plantation businesses, cooperatives, plasma farmers, indigenous groups, and civil society organisations. Thematic analysis was used to analyse semi-structured interviews, field observations, and document analysis. Three governance mechanisms—coordination, collaboration, and institutional learning—determine the effectiveness of plasma partnerships. These techniques improve openness, stakeholder trust, equitable benefit-sharing, accountability, and conflict resolution, helping institutions adapt to complex socio-ecological and governance issues. The study proposes the AIGM, which views sustainable plasma partnerships as the result of Institutional Challenges, Adaptive Institutional Governance, Effective Plasma Partnerships, and Sustainable Oil Palm Development. The model integrates adaptive governance and collaborative institutional learning into a single analytical framework to extend Institutional Governance Theory. The AIGM provides a transportable governance framework for developing sustainable plasma partnerships and insights for institutional governance and plantation policy in emerging economies with comparable governance challenges. 

Keywords: Adaptive Institutional Governance Model (AIGM); Plasma Partnerships; Institutional Governance; Sustainable Palm Oil Development; Collaborative Governance; South Papua.

Received on: 06/03/2025, Revised on: 27/05/2025, Accepted on: 28/08/2025, Published on: 12/09/2026

DOI: 10.69888/FTSML.2026.000820

FMDB Transactions on Sustainable Management Letters, 2026 Vol. 4 No. 3, Pages: 108-116

  • Views : 23
  • Downloads : 8
Download PDF